Free US shipping · 60-day catch guarantee

Mascall Mill Buy
A Better Mousetrap · Part 22 of 30

4,400 patents

Act III: Four hundred years of resetting ·

Listen · 2 min

Card for part 22 of A Better Mousetrap: the number 4,400 in large red type, then the title, 4,400 patents, and the line: Fewer than two dozen ever earned a cent.
Mascall Mill

Part 21 ended with John Mast’s patent of 1903, a trap made safer to set. It was one patent among a great many. By the time a magazine counted them, there were thousands.

More than 4,400

In October 1996, Jack Hope wrote the history of the mousetrap for American Heritage. “Since it first opened for business in 1838,” he wrote, “the U.S. Patent Office reports that it has granted more than 4400 mousetrap patents, 95 percent of them to amateur inventors.”

Our chart: a grid of 4,400 small dark squares, 100 across and 44 down, fills in row by row, one square for each US mousetrap patent American Heritage counted in 1996. Then 24 squares at the bottom left turn red, marked “two dozen”. Fewer than that many ever earned their inventors a cent.

Forty a year, every year

They kept coming. “Roughly forty new mousetrap patents are granted each year, every year,” Hope wrote, “and ten times that many mousetrap patent applications are turned away.”

Our chart: 440 small squares in 11 rows of 40. The first row of 40 is red, the mousetrap patents granted in a year. The other 400 are pale grey, the applications turned away.

A menu of subclasses

The Patent Office sorted them into “thirty-nine official subclasses.” Hope lists some of their names: “Impaling,” “Smiting,” “Swinging Striker,” “Nonreturn Entrance,” “Choking or Squeezing,” “Constricting Noose” and “Electrocuting and Explosive.”

To be granted, a trap didn’t have to be good. Hope notes that the Patent Office “does not require that a device be practical or efficient.” It “requires merely that it will do more or less what the inventor claims it will do.”

Fewer than two dozen

Of the more than 4,400 mousetraps patented in US history, Hope wrote, “fewer than two dozen have ever earned their creators a cent in the marketplace.”

He also named what sank the rest. At the turn of the century, he wrote, “the three great truths of unsuccessful mousetrap design—excess complexity, excess gore, and excess price” had already been shown by “the commercial failure of all but a handful of the thousand or so patented traps already in existence.”

Thousands of inventors had tried. A few traps sold.

Next, part 23: the strangest ones.

Sources

  1. Jack Hope, "A Better Mousetrap", American Heritage, vol. 47 no. 6, October 1996: americanheritage.com/better-mousetrap . The patent counts, the subclass names, what the Patent Office requires, the "three great truths" and "fewer than two dozen" are all from it.